-
Archives
- November 2026
- January 2026
- November 2025
- December 2024
- November 2024
- October 2024
- July 2024
- June 2024
- February 2024
- November 2023
- August 2023
- May 2023
- January 2023
- May 2022
- April 2022
- March 2022
- February 2022
- January 2022
- December 2021
- June 2021
- April 2021
- March 2021
- August 2020
- July 2020
- June 2020
- February 2020
- January 2020
- November 2019
- July 2019
- June 2019
- May 2019
- April 2019
- March 2019
- February 2019
- January 2019
- November 2018
- April 2018
- March 2018
- February 2018
- January 2018
- December 2017
- June 2017
- April 2017
- March 2017
- February 2017
- January 2017
- December 2016
- November 2016
- October 2016
- August 2016
- July 2016
- June 2016
- May 2016
- April 2016
- March 2016
- February 2016
- January 2016
- December 2015
- November 2015
- October 2015
- September 2015
- August 2015
- July 2015
- June 2015
- May 2015
- April 2015
- March 2015
- February 2015
- January 2015
- December 2014
- November 2014
- October 2014
- September 2014
- August 2014
- July 2014
- June 2014
- May 2014
- April 2014
- March 2014
- February 2014
- January 2014
- December 2013
- November 2013
- October 2013
- September 2013
- August 2013
- July 2013
- June 2013
- May 2013
- April 2013
- March 2013
- February 2013
- January 2013
- December 2012
- November 2012
- October 2012
- September 2012
- August 2012
- July 2012
- June 2012
- May 2012
- April 2012
- March 2012
- February 2012
- January 2012
- December 2011
- November 2011
- October 2011
- September 2011
- August 2011
-
Meta
USE YOUR LOAF: BELFAST 1974
In May 1974, the Ulster Workers’ Council brought Norn Iron to a virtual standstill.
The strike was directed against the Sunningdale Agreement and the power-sharing Executive, which had been established only a few months earlier.
Electricity supplies were disrupted, petrol became difficult to obtain, and ordinary everyday life became increasingly complicated.
And, of course, there were shortages.
These days, we’re being encouraged to think about stockpiling supplies in case of nuclear war. Three days’ worth of food, water and other essentials.
Well, anybody who lived through the Ulster Workers’ Council strike will remember that stockpiling was hardly a new idea.
Even bread could become difficult to obtain.
At the time, I was 22 years old, still living with my parents, and a member of the SDLP.
I was a fairly earnest young man with fairly definite political principles.
A Knock at the Door
One evening, there was a knock at our front door.
My mother answered it. Women always answered the front doors. Protecting their husbands, fathers, sons and brothers.
Anyway, standing at the door were a couple of people who identified themselves as representing the Robert Emmet Sinn Féin Cumann.
It’s worth remembering that Sinn Féin in 1974 was nothing like the major political organisation it subsequently became.
It was a relatively marginal political movement, closely associated with the republican movement and the IRA.
I seem to remember the historian Brian Feeney describing the Sinn Féin of those days in terms of the non-combatants of the republican movement: the mothers, wives, fathers and other supporters who were not necessarily involved in armed activity.
Certainly, Sinn Féin wasn’t then the electoral force it would become decades later.
But back to the front door.
The visitors had brought two loaves of bread. “Compliments of Robert Emmett Sinn Féin Cumann”.
Apparently, supplies had been obtained from somewhere outside the immediate area, perhaps from across the border, and were being distributed to local households.
My mother accepted the bread and brought it into the house.
She told me where it had come from.
I was horrified.
“We can’t accept that!”
My mother looked at me.
“We’re SDLP people. We can’t be taking bread from Sinn Féin.”
I was quite insistent.
And so my mother went back outside, found the people who were still making their way along the street, and returned the two loaves.
“My son says we can’t take it.”
There.
Principle established.
Political integrity preserved.
I was quite pleased with myself.
Breakfast
The following morning, I was sitting at the table having my breakfast.
Tea and toast.
Nothing particularly unusual about that.
I finished my breakfast and went off to work.
It was only later that something occurred to me.
Hang on.
I thought we didn’t have any bread.
Where had the toast come from?
When I got home, I asked my mother.
“Where did you get that bread?”
She looked at me.
“You don’t need to know.”
Now, that was an interesting answer.
Naturally, I wanted to know.
Eventually, the truth emerged.
My mother had gone to the woman who lived behind us, the neighbour with whom she regularly exchanged news and gossip over the back fence.
And she had asked her a little favour.
When the people from the Robert Emmett Sinn Féin Cumann came around, could the neighbour get a couple of loaves for her?
And that was exactly what happened.
The bread had made its way into our house by a slightly different route. The Back Door.
I protested.
“But Mammy, we said we wouldn’t take bread from Sinn Féin!”
My mother was completely unmoved.
“But I didn’t get it from Sinn Féin. I got it from the woman over the back fence.”
And there you have it.
I had my political principles.
My mother had two loaves of bread.
My mother was very much part of that world.
Our Daily Bread
I sometimes think back to that little episode.
The Ulster Workers’ Council strike was an enormously significant political event. It helped bring down the power-sharing Executive and demonstrated just how fragile political arrangements in Norn Iron could be.
Historians have written books about it.
Politicians have argued about it for more than fifty years.
But one of my clearest memories of those days is sitting at the breakfast table eating toast that, according to my own political principles, should never have existed.
My mother had found a way around the problem.
She hadn’t argued with me.
She hadn’t challenged my political convictions.
She had simply accepted that her son was entitled to his principles.
And then made sure he had his breakfast.
I suppose there’s a lesson in there somewhere.
I knew where I stood politically.
My mother knew where to get the bread.
And in May 1974, she was probably the wiser of the two of us.
Men like me want to tell our story. But actually it is the women who know the stuff.
Posted in Uncategorized
Tagged politics, Ireland, History, writing, food, Sunningdale, Ulster Workers Council
Leave a comment
BORN TO BE MILD
It was a Saturday afternoon in 1977, and I was on the top deck of a bus going up the Whiterock Road.
There was just me at the back and a group of lads at the front.
And the bus passed a British Army foot patrol. And the lads started shouting abuse out the windows.
So far… so normal.
But the foot patrol gave chase, Ran after the bus shouting at the driver to stop. And as they gained ground, the youths shouted at the driver to go faster.
And as the bus stopped and the Army got on board came up the stairs, I thought “hmm this is not good”.
They looked at me and ignored me. Although it was a Saturday, I was wearing a suit. Tip for those of you worrying about what to do when the Troubles start up again… always wear a suit. For some strange reason, the British Army are conditioned to think that their enemies only wear denim.
Of course, the youths on the bus thought they were dead men… or at least severely beaten up men… but actually the “Brits” just laughed at them saying things like “you’re not so mouthy now Paddy”. And the youths got very sheepish, and it could have been a lot worse.
But as this kind of thing was happening far too often, I decided I would buy a motorcycle.
Travelling on a bus or in a black taxi or even just walking, I always thought that my fate was in the hands of other people.
Besides motorcycles are cool.
So the next week, I went to Donegall Pass and bought a Honda C50… and Paniers (is that the word?) gloves and a white full face Bell helmet.
If I looked the part… the Honda C50 didn’t.
But to be clear, it IS a motorcycle NOT a moped.
Being a biker of sorts, I had to get a provisional driving licence. Forty-plus years later, I can’t recall if Provisional licences then had photo ID, but at least it was some kind of identification.
Of course, motorcycles are very cool. Easy Rider and all that!. And girls love a bad boy biker. I was really in a position to impress Theresa and Barbara.
After all, if I was an American biker called Jimmy and I went to a candy store. I could meet a girl called Betty who wouldn’t mind I came from the wrong side of the tracks. She would fall for me… the Leader of the Pack. (Admittedly it may not end well). Don’t mention Twinkle and Terry.
It is challenging to strike up a pose as a the Leader of the Pack when you only have a Honda C50.
My best friend and co-worker, Peter probably got it right when I parked the C50 in the car park. I might have thought “Easy Rider” but he said I was “born to be …MILD”
And the three local yobs who shared another Honda C50 (no helmet, no licence, no insurance) creatively and obscenely amended the words of Jasper Carrott’s “Funky Moped” just for me but if I could get the speed up to 15mph before I got to Whiterock Road, I could not hear the derision.
Besides…the joke was on them….it wasn’t a Moped.
And they missed the point… because if I got the speed up to 33mph as I passed the grandstand on the Dundrod Circuit, I felt like I was on my way to meet Suzi Quatro… down at, down at, down at Devil Gate Drive.
One morning, I went outside and I noticed that the brake light was missing. Stolen.
Later that evening, the three yobs were riding around and had a brake light in full working order. Indeed they drove past me in a way that the Sioux or Apaches have scalps of their enemies.
Not much I could do about it except go over on a Saturday on a bus to Castlereagh Road to a motorcycle parts shop to get a new brake light. My mother would not let me go alone to East Belfast.
So a new brake light fitted.
But a few days later, something strange happened. The three yobs were at my front door, and they had… incredibly and coincidently… found my brake light. Someone had stolen it… hidden it and by chance the three yobs found it.
Well I had too much dignity to accept my own brake light from the thieves who stole it. So I just said “its all sorted …forget it”
But there was a look of panic across the three faces.
They looked at each other.
“Take it” they pleaded.
“No” I said.
Then one leaned towards me “Mister, please take it…The men at the corner said we have to give it to you”.
So down at the corner of the cul-de-sac were two guys looking towards us. And I looked away from them as I did not want to remember the faces.
And I got the message and took the brake light.
Now who were those two guys who clearly had enough influence to persuade three lawless thugs to return stolen property?
See… the mantra that I always heard from unionist leaning bosses and British Army spokesman on TV was that nationalists in Ballymurphy. Ardoyne, Andytown etc were really unionists at heart and were intimidated by republican paramilitaries.
Undoubtedly the atmosphere was scary.
But within the demographic in these working class areas (and Id guess the same in unionist Glencairn, Rathcoole and Gilnahirk etc) there was a sizeable demographic of people termed “quiet”, “good living”, “Christian” whatever and two guys watching at the corner of the cul-de-sac understood the nuances.
A sniper in Springmartin intent on killing or a carload from the Village bent on abduction and torture would not have cared. And the foot patrol chasing a bus up the Whiterock Road would have been problematic… but wearing a suit helped.
The real hero of this story is my mother. Her son had just had a brake light stolen. She mentioned it to neighbour and she knew that the neighbour had a husband who.just might know somebody who might know somebody else who might know two men who would strongly advise three thugs to return some stolen property.
PASS THE DOOBIE ON THE LEFT HAND SIDE
One of the strange things about our recent visit to Glasgow was my wife repeatedly saying, “Can you smell that? Can you smell it? Wacky backy!”
Now, she does this quite a lot. In Belfast, Dublin and, seemingly, Glasgow, she regularly detects what she believes to be the smell of cannabis.
I never smell anything.
Indeed, it has always been a feature of our marriage that my wife can smell things that are completely lost on me.
“Can you smell gas?”
“No.”
“Can you smell the dinner burning?”
“No.”
“Can you smell smoke? Somebody’s burning something somewhere.”
“No.”
Even when I was in Texas, my best friend would occasionally wind up the car window and announce, “Skunks!”
Again, nothing.
Which brings me to the old joke.
“John Mooney has no nose.”
“How does he smell?”
“Terrible!”
But seriously, I have a very ineffective nose. I don’t know why. I suspect it might have something to do with a knock I received while playing hurling when I was a young teen.
Whatever the reason, my sense of smell is considerably less developed than that of most people.
This has occasionally been useful.
For example, my wife might suggest that she would like some expensive perfume for Christmas. Chanel Number Whatever.
Being a naturally frugal sort of person, I point out that there is really no need to spend a fortune on perfume because I won’t be able to smell it anyway.
For some reason, she doesn’t consider this a particularly romantic argument.
Indeed, she looks at me as if I am some kind of miserable old skinflint.
Which is very unfair.
Anyway, shortly before my fiftieth birthday, the subject of bucket lists came up in conversation at work.
We were discussing things we had never done but might like to try before we died.
I mentioned that I had never smoked a joint.
Now, I had lived through the 1960s, the Summer of Love, flower power, hippies and all the rest of it. Yet somehow I had reached the age of almost fifty without ever trying cannabis.
The following morning, a young female colleague handed me a small metal tube, the sort that expensive cigars sometimes come in.
Naturally, I began to open it.
“Don’t open it here!” she whispered.
Inside were two joints.
Good heavens.
I was now a criminal.
It was a Friday, and I took my unexpected gift home.
On Sunday night, at about 11.30, my wife had gone to bed and our two teenage sons were in their bedrooms.
I decided that the moment had arrived.
Standing in front of a full-length mirror in the , I attempted to recreate the spirit of the 1960s.
Peace, love, flower power.
Puff, puff, puff.
I must have looked ridiculous.
The disappointing thing was that absolutely nothing happened.
No visions. No revelations. No sudden desire to listen to psychedelic music. No creative impulse to write a song.
Nothing.
People have subsequently suggested that I probably wasn’t doing it properly.
Anyway, having completed my brief career as a hippie, I decided to go to bed.
And that was when disaster struck.
My wife suddenly jumped out of bed.
“ONE OF THOSE BOYS IS SMOKING!”
Before I could stop her, she marched into their bedrooms.
“Which one of you is smoking? Where is it? Where have you hidden it?”
Two completely innocent teenagers found themselves subjected to an unexpected late-night investigation.
Meanwhile, their father followed meekly behind.
“I don’t think so, d”
“Well, I can smell it!”
“Really? I can’t smell anything.”
Which, for once, was absolutely true.
Desperate to divert suspicion, I suggested that perhaps the smell came from some candles I had been burning around the bath earlier.
Now, anyone who knows me will appreciate how likely it is that I would take a relaxing bath surrounded by scented candles.
Not very.
I then suggested that perhaps someone had been smoking outside and the smell had drifted through an open window.
Unfortunately, we have a fairly large garden, which made this explanation equally unconvincing.
My wife led an unlikely parade thru bedrooms, bathroom, kitchen, living room….and three of us sniffing like bloodhounds.
The boys returned to their rooms, presumably wondering what on earth had happened.
And I escaped prosecution.
There was still the second joint.
I eventually smoked it while walking down the Stewartstown Road on my way to work in Belfast.
Again, absolutely nothing happened.
I quickly disposed of the evidence.
And that, as far as I can recall, was the beginning and end of my criminal career.
But the real tragedy of this story came some twenty years later.
During a family conversation, I casually mentioned that I had smoked cannabis shortly before my fiftieth birthday.
My family looked at me.
Disbelief.
Complete disbelief.
Apparently, the idea of their husband, father, father in law, grandfather standing in front of a mirror pretending to be a 1960s hippie was simply beyond their imagination.
Nobody believed me
And that, I think, is the saddest part of this whole sorry episode.
Not that I have a defective sense of smell.
Not that my wife has the nose of a bloodhound.
Not even that two innocent teenagers were falsely accused of smoking in their own bedrooms.
No.
The real tragedy is discovering that I am apparently so boring that my own family refuse to believe I have ever done anything remotely interesting in my life.
BLOOD PRESSURE MONITOR: A GAME BOY FOR HYPOCHONDRIACS
Blood pressure. What exactly is it?
Well, I haven’t the faintest idea. But apparently I have a problem with it.
If you’ve ever watched medical dramas like Grey’s Anatomy or Casualty, you’ll know that sooner or later somebody announces that a patient’s blood pressure is 476 over 99, or perhaps a million over three.
Everybody looks terribly concerned.
I’ve never understood what any of those numbers mean.
Of course, I’ve had my blood pressure taken many times. Fall over, bang your head, turn up at A&E, and somebody immediately produces one of those cuffs and wraps it around your arm.
In the old days, they would invariably tell me that everything was normal.
Excellent.
But what was normal? Nobody ever said. And since I was apparently normal, I never thought to ask.
Then, in 2016, I went to see my GP about something entirely routine. It might even have been an insurance matter.
He took one look at me.
“Good God, John. You look terrible.”
Thank you, Doctor. Always reassuring.
He decided to take my blood pressure.
The result was apparently not good. Not good at all.
He arranged for one of the practice nurses to attach a complicated little machine to me. This contraption would monitor my blood pressure at intervals throughout the following 24 hours.
When I returned to have it removed, I asked the nurse what the actual numbers were.
She told me.
I immediately forgot them.
“Could you write those down for me?”
She did.
I went out to the car and showed the piece of paper to my wife.
“Oh my God! You’re going to have a stroke!”
Which, I thought, was precisely the sort of announcement likely to bring one on.
Anyway, that was 2016, and I’ve been prescribed blood pressure medication ever since.
When I say I’ve been taking medication for ten years, what I actually mean is that I’ve been taking it when I thought I needed it.
Not necessarily every day.
I know. I know.
Now, about six weeks ago, something rather interesting happened.
I went into a local pharmacy and bought myself a blood pressure monitor.
Wonderful invention.
A Game Boy for hypochondriacs.
You put the cuff on, press a button, and wait for the machine to tell you whether you’re going to survive until teatime.
My wife and I have had great fun taking each other’s blood pressure.
It’s the sort of thing older married couples do for entertainment when they’ve exhausted all the other possibilities.
And the really exciting part is that you can compare your readings with a chart published by the National Health Service.
Different numbers. Different colours.
Green, amber, red.
Rather like traffic lights, except that the red light appears to be telling you that you’re about to have a medical emergency.
To my considerable surprise, I was frequently in the red zone.
On a few occasions, the advice was to phone 111.
Now, I thought, this can’t be right.
So I contacted my GP practice.
And, to my even greater surprise, the doctor actually phoned me back.
She decided to increase my medication.
Fair enough.
She also wanted me to have a blood test after a couple of weeks, followed by another appointment to discuss the results.
Simple enough, you might think.
A week or so ago, I duly arrived at the surgery for the blood test.
And I must say, the nurse was excellent. For perhaps the first time in my life, somebody managed to find a vein without it immediately collapsing in protest.
I mentioned that the doctor wanted to see me again in two weeks.
“Could you arrange an appointment?”
“Oh no,” said the nurse. “You’ll have to do that at reception.”
Fair enough.
Off I went to reception.
“The doctor wants to see me in two weeks to discuss the results of the blood test I’ve just had.”
“Oh no, John. We can’t do that.”
“Why not?”
“You have to phone next Wednesday, when the appointments for the following week are released, and try to get one.”
Try?
“But the nurse told me to come out here and make the appointment.”
“No, we can’t do that.”
“But she said—”
The receptionist went off to consult the nurse.
She returned.
“No, John. You’ll have to phone next Wednesday and try to get an appointment.”
And there we were.
The doctor wanted to see me.
The nurse told me to make an appointment.
Reception couldn’t make the appointment.
And I was supposed to telephone on a particular Wednesday and compete for the privilege of seeing the doctor who had already said she wanted to see me.
I never did get the appointment.
Meanwhile, I’m taking the increased medication, checking my blood pressure, and watching the numbers move between a little high and very high.
Apparently, one reason for the blood test is to check how my kidneys are coping with the medication.
Which is something else I hadn’t known.
You see, I’m not really a hypochondriac.
I just worry that I’ve got every illness known to medical science. I wonder if there is a word for people with my condition.
And now I’ve bought myself a machine that allows me to worry about them electronically.
Progress.
Either way, welcome to the National Health Service.
Posted in Uncategorized
Tagged blood pressure, Family, health, life, Mental Health, writing
2 Comments
THE RUSSIANS ARE COMING! THE RUSSIANS ARE COMING!
BE READY is the name of the British government’s campaign requesting its citizens to stockpile in the event of a Russian attack.
Now I don’t know if this is pessimistic or optimistic, but citizens are advised to stockpile for three days.
Not sure that three days is actually “stockpiling’ You would really expect a war to last so much longer than three days. So is it optimistic? Is it pessimistic? Either way, this instruction does not apply to me or indeed to a lot of people in Norn Iron because a lot of us aren’t actually British citizens.
And I don’t know what the right approach is. I’m a citizen of a neutral country. So, well, do I paint a red cross on the roof of our house and pretend we are a hospital? Or if a Russian drone is hovering overhead, do I go out and wave my Irish/EU passport at it or simply direct them three miles up the road? There are a lot of British people three miles
Hard to know. The point is that here we have become so immune to violence that telling us to fear the Russians or anyone else for that matter is almost irrelevant. History tells us we have more to fear from people around us than people who are thousands of miles away
Now of course I am overstating the case. People would point out “emergency stocking up is not just about the Russians landing on the beach in Portrush and upsetting the surfers. It’s as much to do with bad weather, cyber attack and all kinds of things. And three days is just the initial response.
But I’d also like to point out that Sky TV actually a couple of months ago produced a drama documentary called War Game which set out how a British Russian conflict would go.
The striking thing was that the Americans probably wouldn’t intervene. And that the Europeans would probably not intervene either. And that within just a couple of days the British would send off their entire nuclear arsenal. And then be completely and absolutely obliterated.
Of course that was a government that was apparently led by Michael Gove, Nicola Sturgeon and Penny Mordaunt. So maybe a government led by Andy Burnham would be better. Or maybe could bring back Liz Truss
Of course, we are all familiar with the last time there was a world war, Second World War…that was the name.
And Norn Iron was the only part of the United Kingdom that was exempt from conscription. Now maybe three reasons.
First of all, you could say that it would have taken a lot of regiments to round up Catholics who would not be particularly willing to go off to fight for the UK.
And you could say that it was the unionist population suddenly discovering that they had essential jobs that unfortunately prevented them going off to fight a war.
Or you could say that a lot of unionists looked around at the First World War and looked at the Somme and other battlefields and decided they didn’t really want to do that all again.
And maybe they thought it was advisable to guard against some kind of fifth column of nationalists within Norn Iron
Either way, the Second World War and discussion of it and Ireland’s neutrality.
didn’t Ireland sign a bit of condolence for Adolf Hitler? And weren’t we neutral and denying essential ports to Britain?
Or did we supply the weather forecast that helped the D-Day? and didn’t we send the Dublin fire engines to Belfast to put out the fires? A very great brrach of neutrality by the way. And didn’t we warn, is ‘warn”he right word, warn the Germans that any attack on the north of Ireland would be regarded as an attack on all of Ireland?
We really, we really scared the life out of the SS and all those planners or maybe it just suited everybody that Ireland was neutral.
Certainly it suited a lot of people in Belfast who were fire watching for planes that never actually came. So there’s a lot of nonsense talked about the Second World War, a lot of tropes I suppose is the right word coming from both sides.
And I imagine the Third World War would be no different. It’s easy to imagine me outside waving an Irish passport, a European passport at Russian drones.
But three miles up the road as the Russian drones approach, quite possibly a lot of people will be unexpectedly out shouting “tiocfaidh ár lá”at Russian drones
COMEDY TONIGHT
Part Five — The Comedians
As everyone knows, I am hilarious.
I have mentioned this before, but some people appear to require reminding.
In June 1971, Granada Television introduced The Comedians, a programme built around an astonishingly simple idea.
Get a collection of stand-up comedians, put them in front of an audience, and let them tell jokes.
No elaborate sets.
No complicated plots.
No actors pretending to be bus conductors.
Just comedians.
The programme brought the world of working men’s clubs, variety theatres and northern entertainment circuits into millions of living rooms.
Bernard Manning, Frank Carson, Charlie Williams, Ken Goodwin, Colin Crompton and others became familiar television personalities.
There was no need for an elaborate introduction.
A comedian appeared, delivered a succession of jokes, and made way for the next performer.
The pace was relentless.
There was little opportunity to recover from a bad joke because another one was already on its way.
Frank Carson, from Belfast, became famous for his infectious enthusiasm and his catchphrases.
“It’s the way I tell ’em” became almost as recognisable as the man himself.
Bernard Manning represented another tradition entirely.
Loud, confident, aggressive and unapologetically working-class, Manning could dominate a room through sheer force of personality.
He was also a controversial performer, particularly because of his jokes about race and ethnicity.
Charlie Williams, a former professional footballer, was another prominent figure. His routines frequently involved racial humour, sometimes directed at himself.
And that raises a difficult question.
What happens when an audience laughs at a joke about race?
Are they laughing with the comedian?
At the comedian?
At the people being described?
Or at something else entirely?
The answer depends on the joke, the performer, the audience and the circumstances.
It is tempting to divide the comedy of that period into two categories: acceptable and unacceptable.
But history is seldom so accommodating.
The comedians were performing for audiences whose expectations had been formed by a very different society.
That does not excuse every joke.
Nor does it mean that everyone at the time approved of them.
There were objections to racist and sexist humour long before the twenty-first century. The idea that nobody questioned such material until recently is itself a rewriting of history.
Yet the performers were popular, and their popularity is part of the historical record.
To understand the comedy, we need to understand the audiences.
Working men’s clubs occupied an important place in British social life. They offered entertainment, companionship, cheap drink and a sense of community.
The comedians who succeeded in those rooms developed particular skills.
They could handle hecklers.
They could judge the mood of an audience.
They could change direction when a joke failed.
And they knew that a room full of people who had paid to be entertained could be considerably less forgiving than a television audience.
The club comedian was often part storyteller, part actor and part survivor.
The jokes were frequently old.
Some were ancient.
A good performer could make an old joke sound new simply through timing, expression and delivery.
That was a skill in itself.
The arrival of The Comedians on television gave performers from this tradition a national platform.
It also exposed the limitations of their material.
A joke that worked in a particular club, among people who shared assumptions and experiences, might sound very different when broadcast to a national audience.
And as British society changed, the distance between those audiences grew.
By the late 1970s and into the 1980s, alternative comedy was beginning to challenge the established circuit.
The new performers rejected many of the conventions of club comedy, particularly its reliance on racial stereotypes, sexism and predictable mother-in-law jokes.
But alternative comedy did not emerge from nowhere.
The Goons, Beyond the Fringe, Monty Python and other innovators had already demonstrated that comedy could be absurd, intellectual, political and deliberately unconventional.
What changed was the wider audience’s willingness to embrace those alternatives.
The old comedians did not all disappear.
Some adapted.
Others continued performing to audiences who remained loyal to them.
And a few became symbols of everything the new generation wanted to reject.
Looking back, I find myself resisting the temptation to divide the performers neatly into heroes and villains.
Comedy is more complicated than that.
A comedian may be technically brilliant and politically objectionable.
A joke may be funny and cruel.
An audience may laugh without examining why.
And the passage of time may transform something once considered harmless into something deeply uncomfortable.
None of this means we should stop examining the past.
Quite the opposite.
Comedy provides an unusually revealing record of what a society believed, feared, desired and was prepared to tolerate.
We can learn a great deal about Britain in the 1970s by examining what made its people laugh.
And sometimes what made them laugh tells us things they might not have admitted in a serious conversation.
There is another question worth considering.
Have we become less tolerant of comedy?
Or have we become more conscious of the people who were once expected to endure being its targets?
Again, I suspect the answer is both.
The old club comedians belonged to a particular world.
That world has largely disappeared.
But its influence remains, sometimes in unexpected places.
And if we are going to tell the history of British comedy, we cannot simply edit out the people whose jokes we no longer enjoy.
They were there.
Millions watched them.
Millions laughed.
And that, whether we approve or not, is part of the story.
Comedy Tonight will continue.