A Tale Of Two Sinn Féin Posters

So here is an odd thing. An Election conducted on Proportional Representation. And two posters.

Take Cat Seeley, one of two Sinn Féin candidates in Upper Bann. Seemingly she has been designated to get the #1s in Lurgan area. But her posters indicate that her supporters should give second preferences to running mate, John O’Dowd.

image

image

Contrast this with former Fermanagh-South Tyrone Sinn Féin MP, who was left off her Party’s three man (sic) ticket. All of the chosen candidates were from Fermanagh. Ms Gildernew was added at a second convention. Not surprisingly, she has been allocated the South Tyrone part of the constituency.
But curiously all of her posters (and Dungannon had a lot) does not offer any guidance on second, third and fourth preferences. It is a very curious form of vote management.

 

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , | 8 Comments

Kick The Tories When They Are On The Ground

Not literally of course.

But increasingly the EU Referendum looks like an opportunity to bring down the Tory Government. Even allowing for the fact that General Elections are now fixed at every five years and Cameron’s Government has not yet completed its first year, it looks increasingly likely that the Conservative Party will tear itself apart …and as always the issue is Europe. There should be no problem in helping the process along.

The irony is that the sole purpose of the EU Referendum was to keep the Tories in power. Worried by the rise of a Europhobic party like UKIP and the ever present Tory backwoods men, David Cameron promised to re-negotiate Britains membership of the European Union and put the revised terms to the people of Britain in a Referendum.

Having won the 2015, General Election, David Cameron spent most of the winter jetting around Europe talking to other governments and rather like his Tory predecessor, Anthony Eden in 1938, landed back in London waving a piece of paper.

Of course it was always the case that the re-negotiations were a cosmetic exercise. Cameron obviously presents it all as a triumph but UKIP, Labour skeptics and Tory “Little Englanders” see thru it. Indeed Tory “europhobes” probably make up the majority of the Party.

We therefore have the curiousity of the Referendum being more or less a debate that is outside the normal Tory-Labour divide. Indeed while six of Cameron’s cabinet campaign to leave the EU ….and still remain members of the Cabinet, the majority of the Labour Party are committed to staying in the EU.

Increasingly Cameron looks like he has outsmarted himself. Increasingly the “IN” people are resorting to the tactics of Fear…jobs will be lost, Britain will be more insecure against the threat of terrorism etc. The problem with the “Fear” tactic is that it was used less than two years ago by the coalition of unionists (Tory, Labour and Lib Dem and banks and big business) that defeated the referendum on Scottish Independence (September 2014). The Scots were conned. And punished the unionist parties in Westminster Election less than a year later.

Having seen the Scots conned, it looks like the people of England are suspicious of Government information, including an explanatory booklet due to be delivered to every home in England next week. This explanatory booklet has been denounced as “taxpayer funded Government propaganda” …..by Tory members of the Government!

The situation is getting more bizarre. Cameron rightly points out that the Government is not neutral. And members of his own Government call for signatures to an online petition condemning the mis-use of taxpayers money.

Any hope that David Cameron had that his Party could reasonably disagree on such a major Government  policy and then come together after the result of the Referendum looks forlorn. And the survival of his government looks increasingly dependant on Labour goodwill. And the secrets of the “Panama Papers” hangs over Tory toffs.

I am not for one minute suggesting that voting to leave the EU is a legitimate tactic to overthrow the Tories. People should make up their minds on what is best for them and their children. What is right for Scotland, Wales and Norn Iron (or Ireland itself) is not necessarily right for Greater England, England or even the English regions (the City of London for example).

Anyone contemplating an “OUT” vote needs to consider the people they are supporting….Michael Gove, Ian Duncan-Smith, John Redwood, Boris Johnson, Nigel Farage, Arlene Foster, Jim Allister and Kate Hoey….and the Daily Mail and Daily Express.

On the other hand, anyone contemplating an “IN” vote needs to deal with supporting David Ford, Naomi Long, Vernon Coaker ,the big banks and the Norn Iron Independent Retailers Association.

But there are two points. Your “IN” or “OUT” vote should not depend on the strange bedfellows that are a consequence of these cross-party campaigns. Rather this is a manufactured campaign to maintain Tory unity. People who oppose Tories can still vote “IN” and undermine the Tory government. For example that online petition.

Sign the Petition. You know it makes sense.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , | 6 Comments

SDLP Launch Newry & Armagh Campaign.

Armagh City Hotel last night. SDLP members and friends gathered to formally launch the election campaign in Newry & Armagh.

Among the speakers, Deputy Leader, Fearghal McKinney, who introduced Justin McNulty and Karen McKevitt.

image

The two candidate strategy is designed to bring in two MLAs.The constituency has been divided for canvassing purposes with Justin being allocated Armagh area and Karen being allocated the area around Newry and South Armagh.

image

Justin McNulty is a member of a SDLP “family” and was a member of the Armagh team which won the All-Ireland in 2002. So there is a name recognition factor and he was the Party’s candidate in last years Westminster Election. Some quotes from his speech….”we will not perpetuate Fear”, “our voters are out there waiting for us” and “this constituency has had two successive Roads Ministers and we have the worst roads”.

image

Karen McKevitt is outgoing MLA for South Down. Her speech referenced victims of the Troubles, including the murders of the Reavey brothers (committed by loyalists), the Kingsmill Massacre (committed by republicans) and the more recent brutal  murder  of Paul Quinn.

image

The overall mood was one of genuine affection for the candidates and outgoing MLA, Dominic Bradley who has been a major advocate for the Irish language and for Autism. Dominic is the Campaign Manager and a lot of his speech was about the logistics of the campaign.

Can two seats be won? Well, certainly people I talked to detect a change in the conversations they are having on doorsteps. But as  always, a major factor will be the turnout on 5th May.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , | 2 Comments

Jefferson Davis Presidential Library

Interesting postcard received from a friend in United States of America.

image

Jefferson Davis was President of the Confederate States of America. The Presidential Library is located in Biloxi, Mississippi. It is situated in eighty-two acres and was rebuilt following damage by Hurricane Katrina in 2005.

All conventional Presidential Libraries are unsurprisingly dedicated to the life and works of a President. Necessarily they see a President in a favourable light.

I note the library seems to fly the flag of United States and a Confederate flag. The question arises how this Library sees itself…and how others see it…..in 2016.

It is also interesting from the perspective of Conflict Resolution. The Confederacy was defeated. It’s last flag was a white one. Or was the Confederacy ever really defeated? Did the War really end in 1865….or did the brief experiment in Reconstruction and the handover (for a century) to white segregationalists, backed by the Ku Klux Klan, ensure that the Confederacy actually won in several respects?

Contrast the reality of a Jefferson Davis Presidential Museum with the notion of a Museum in Germany…dedicated to Adolf Hitler.

All trappings of Nazism are banned in Germany. The form of Conflict Resolution in Germany has been to crush the Nazis. Yet in the southern States…the Confederacy is celebrated…often in nasty racist ways. But often in terms of anti-federal “States Rights” and of a lost cause which was heroic, if flawed.

Which is better?

 

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , | 2 Comments

Game of (West) Tyrones

I really had no intention of doing a post on the Sinn Féin defection (Sorcha McAnespy) in West Tyrone. A regular reader of this Blog (“Sinn Féin Supporter in West Tyrone”) raised it in a comment and kindly stated that there was nothing to see here and it was all sour grapes. I of course saw a pattern …look at Fermanagh-South Tyrone.

That is of course what Bloggers and “commenters” do…talk up problems in other parties and minimise the problems in their own.

So…West Tyrone. The basics are that there are six Assembly seats and four will be nationalist and two will be unionist. It should be simple…until we look at disaffection within both SF and SDLP.

Of the four nationalist seats, it is certain three will be go to Sinn Féin, not least because SDLP is only fielding one candidate.

Although, Sorcha McAnespy is standing as an Independent, she has stated that she is not in disagreement with any SF policy. Her beef is with the local party…favouritism and nepotism with a dash of bias against women. I cant see her winning a seat. These internal disputes look bad to voters but realistically outside her own base, I cant see her attracting much support. It is an irritation for Sinn Féin but not a serious problem.

SDLP is also dealing with the fall-out of two local SDLP councillors resigning.And theres some similarity. But arguably, SDLP problems are more deep rooted.

In 2003 Assembly SDLP lost a seat to a local Independent, a doctor. And in 2005 Westminster Election polled badly against him. But fielding three candidates in 2007, polling more than a quota and still not managing a quota was ample evidence of poor vote management and a divided party.
Having no MLA in West Tyrone seems like a watershed.
Joe Byrne won back the seat in 2011 and there is strong evidence that SDLP has made steady improvement in 2014 and 2015….Daniel McCrossan having a comfortable quota in the Westminster race.
I first heard Daniel speak at the 2011 SDLP Conference and it was very evident that he was both MLA material and had the ambition to become one. It was also evident that he was Joe Byrnes heir apparent.
The personality clashes have never really gone away. Patsy Kelly in Strabane has always seemed semi-detached.
But the emergence of Dr Jo Deehan in Omagh seems a bigger problem. Certainly before the emergence of Daniel, she seemed the most likely successor. She missed out in 2007 and realistically that was her chance gone.
Daniel was selected as an Assembly candidate …the sole candidate…for the 2016 Election. Perhaps understandably Dr Deehan and her supporters felt she should also be on the ticket. The case was made that it was about gender balance and geographical balance.

My own position is clear but nuanced.
1 there is one SDLP quota in West Tyrone.
2 a second (female and Omagh-based) candidate WOULD add to the SDLP vote.
3 that increase would not be enough to elect a second candidate.
4 it MIGHT elect Dr Deehan rather than Danny.
5 Danny McCrossan is in my view the better candidate.

So running two candidates might elect the “wrong” MLA. Danny is the better person for 2016.
It should also be pointed out that since his co-option (Joe Byrne has been in ill health) to the Assembly, Danny has been brilliant and has of course an advantage.
Really running two candidates would run the risk of Danny losing out to a running mate but I think a small risk worth taking in the name of unity.
To be clear, I regard Danny as a friend. I have only come across Dr Deehan once (she chaired a working group at a conference in March 2012). Perhaps unfair to judge on one brief inter-action but I was not impressed.

So it is a distraction we can do without. Both Patsy Kelly and Dr Deehan will stand as Independents. They will damage Danny slightly in Strabane and Omagh but not enough. Much like Sorcha McAnespy and Sinn Féin.

So…few will disagree. Unionists 2 seats…Nationalists 4 (SF 3 SDLP 1).

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , | 9 Comments

Still No Canvassers

For a week now, I have been peeping thru the Venetian blinds looking out for canvassers. Still none. This is disappointing as I feel like a good argument with people who wont actually punch me.

First off, I will be expecting canvassers to close the gate. Its the little things.

The downside of living in a village that is 100 per cent nationalist/Catholic is that we only get SDLP and Sinn Féin. As I am actually a member of the local branch of SDLP, I hope they call to say hello.

Sinn Féin always call…more than once. Their tactic should be interesting. Either they will tell me that SDLP is not “republican” or “nationalist” or they will agree that it is and ask me for a second and third preference.

As always Sinn Féin will use any tactic that they think will work. In 2011, they told me that my SDLP vote was unecessary as the candidate was “safe” and that by voting SF, “we” could take another seat for nationalists. But in another part of the constituency, they told would-be SDLP voters that the candidate was “toast”. So at least Sinn Féin will give me an argument but to be honest I cant be arsed. I probably wont answer the door.

I have never actually seen a unionist canvasser at any house where I have lived. ….West Belfast, Dungannon and this village. To their credit, they have canvassed Catholic homes and while they might not get many votes, they at least take the voter seriously.

SDLP are certainly canvassing non-nationalist areas. Again it is treating voters with courtesy. The reaction….well often the real vitriol comes from committed SF voters. SDLP canvassers across eighteen constituencies seem to be getting good feedback.

The phrase “positive reaction on the doorsteps” is of course standard for every political party. But certainly SDLP have more canvassers out there than in any recent election. They also seem to have started early so that Euro/locals (2014), Westminster (2015) has at least given continuity. The supporters and the “dont knows” are better known and there is a different kinda canvas ongoing with organised groups such as trade unions, charities and pressure groups. Visibility is everything….and a young, Stormont-based Leader like Colum Eastwood pressing the flesh and appearing in very localised media (yesterday it was Castlewellan) might be making a difference. All Politics is local after all.

Yet “positive reaction on the doorsteps” is not in itself a good thing. In 2015, part of the shock of Labour’s collapse in Scotland was that it seemed to contradict at least some canvassing returns. The fact is that too many people had already given up on Labour and thought they were not worth the bother of a doorstep fight.

I live in hope that Alliance…hopefully some cherubic 20something IT consultant will knock my door. They did actually leave us a leaflet (mostly about dog-fouling) in early 2014 but they havent been seen in the village since. I did see an Alliance member from this constituency canvas last year. He was canvassing ….in East Belfast for Saint Naomi Long.

It is a shame….I have my entirely reasonable “Alliance Party are undemocratic scumbags” argument all prepared and they never show up.

For the record, the answer the canvassers hate most is not “I wouldnt vote Alliance/SF/DUP/ UUP if you paid me”. That changes nothing. The response they really hate is “I always vote Alliance/SF/DUP/UUP….but not this time”. Thats the response they dont want to take back to the de-briefing. And as a bonus….you might get re-canvassed at a later date with a “please, please, please dont desert us” and you can enjoy the fact that you are wasting resources of your rival.

Dont forget….walkabouts ….in strange towns. If you have a bus pass and can travel free to Bangor, East Belfast, Antrim , you may be lucky enough to be canvassed by Stephen Farry, Naomi Long and David Ford and you can agonise with them that you are a gene pool letsgetalongerist who will never vote Alliance again.

Remember in canvassing, nobody actually expects you to tell the truth.

 

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged | 11 Comments

A Personal Commemoration

I am not a big fan of flying flags from private houses. Discounting World Cups, I last flew the National Flag at Easter 1971 in West Belfast.

The 1971 Flag was bought in Ardoyne and I brought it home on my Honda C50 motorcycle via Ballygomartin Road. That period between August 1969 and August 1971 was a strange phoney war. People started to make decisions about how they would deal with the Troubles.

As readers of this Blog will know, I lived thru an emotional roller-coaster 1971-72. In the space of a year, we had the Ballymurphy Massacre (a British Army attrocity), McGurks Bar (Loyalist), Bloody Sunday (British Army) Bloody Friday (IRA) and Claudy Bomb (IRA). By May 1973, I had settled as a SDLP member.

image

So at Easter 1971, I flew the Flag from our three-bedroom Housing Executive house in West Belfast. But it flew from my parents bedroom. I basked in the glory of being a bit of a rebel and my parents froze every night of Easter Week….as the window was open.
I did not have the guts to fly the flag at Easter 1972. Most people thought twice about it. It would have been like asking for the “Brits” to raid the house.

So…2016. It seems appropriate. A new Flag bought in Dublin.
And at noon today, I hung it from the spare room. And there it will stay until Saturday afternoon.

Posted in Uncategorized | 4 Comments

Easter Centenary

I think that most people will accept that yesterday’s Commemoration in Dublin was a good day for the Irish Nation …the centre-piece being an ELECTED President and Defence Forces that have never been involved in a war except in their prevention or the maintenance of Peace thru the United Nations.

It was an opportunity to recognise that the Republic that the men and women of 1916 gave us…eventually a nation of which the citizens can be proud. On a personal note, the parents of one of the young cadets in the Guard of Honour are friends. And at least two of the Defence Forces parading yesterday are known to my family. It is a small world. It is a small country.

And it is a good one. Was the Commemoration too inclusive? I dont think so. The men and women who fought in the Easter Rising…especially those who lost their lives…did more than anyone else to create the Republic of Ireland. But they did not EXCLUSIVELY build it. Those who fought in the War of Independence, the creation of the Defence Forces and Garda, the democratic parties, the Emergency Services, the voluntary organisations, the Churches (YES…the Churches!).

Of course there were the orphanages, the Magdalene Women, the bankers, the Golden Circles but a Republic is always a work in progress.

Any unionist peeping over the garden wall into the Republic of Ireland has to conclude that it is a pretty decent place. LetsGetAlongerism obliges us to to say that being Irish and British are equally valid expressions of identity. But nations have an …ethos. And the ethos of the Irish Nation, born a century ago has frankly a better ethos than the so called “United Kingdom”, a hotch potch of spurious beliefs such as monarchy, a hereditary Head of State who is Supreme Governor of an established Church, an Empire and so called-Commonwealth and a Flag that has flown over prison yards in every continent and slave ships on every ocean. A war-like nation who built its capital on the plunder from five continents.

Britain creates its own legitimacy, casually ignoring the inconvenient in 1688 and 1936. Britain had the misfortune to win  two World War Wars, avoiding the revolution that would have overthrown monarchies (as it had in Germany, Austria and Russia). And of course, United States of America and France established their own republics in blood.
Notwithstanding centuries of failed rebellion and British repression, the Easter Rising was comparatively bloodless. The Rebels wore no masks, they primed no car bombs, they targetted no civilians and the positions they occupied were largely defensive. The Surrender was based on the avoidance of civilian deaths. In the clean fight/dirty fight analysis, the balance is in the Rebels favour.

If I love just one thing about the Irish Nation, it is that we are a former colony which is part of the “First World” and suited to have an understanding of the “Third World”. The service to United Nations was usually in response to a colonial or post-colonial crisis.

We have no empire. We sought no Manifest Destiny but our own.  In 1916 we were as despised as much in Woodrow Wilson’s White House as we were in Asquith’s Downing Street. The Easter Rising Was not about proclaiming our nation to be better than any other nation. Our “august destiny” is modestly to be as good as any other nation. Primarily thats the success of this nation…an Irish citizen can look anyone in the face.

I am of course disappointed but not surprised that SDLP for the most part avoided any northern organised events. As I wrote a few months ago, the SDLP can make History but is incapable of dealing with History…especially its own. I was involved in a SDLP meeting re Easter last September but it was pretty obvious to me that nothing would really happen.

Frankly the decision to not do much might actually be the right one. SDLP politicians were in attendance at the Dublin events and there is a certain dignity about that. As an Irish citizen, I would rather channel my respect thru the Irish Nation. Better to have no event in the north, than half-arsed compromises. Nothing could be better than the Dublin show-piece. And maybe the Easter Rising can only be celebrated in Freedom.

Of course I do understand repudiation of violence. I do understand Pacifism and a wariness about the notion of blood sacrifice or the lack of a mandate for Rebellion. I inderstand that some SDLP people, self-style progressives cannot fully throw themselves into the “militarism”.

But there has to be consistency. No point in talking about the importance of “shared history” and openly embracing the Somme Centenary but only the non-militaristic aspects. No point in agonising about the innocent lives lost in Dublin in 1916 and not agonising about the innocent lives lost during World War One.

Likewise no point in accepting an invitation to summer garden party at the French Consulate in Belfast, raise a glass to Liberty, Egality and Fraternity and not agonising about the thousands of innocent lives lost as a consequence of the French Revolution.

There was not much wrong with the Commemoration in Dublin yesterday. In the interests of balance, RTÉ gave too much air-time to the likes of Ruth Dudley-Edwards, Kevin Myers and Michael Portillo but for the most part, it seems the national broadcaster is having a good war.

A word of praise for the drama-documentary “Insurrection” an ambitious nightly half hour prhogramme first shown in 1966. At times, it looks dated and appears like a pageant rather than a drama….but depicting the Rising thru the prism of a modern news programme, with “reporters” present at the events and with “interviews” with the participants. And from a personal perspective, nice to see my fathers cousin (an actor and RTÉ continuity announcer) playing one of the parts.

So….Sinn Féin. Their own events in the north will play well with their core. Might even give them a pre-election boost. But ultimately their claim to be the direct descendants of the Spirit of 1916 looks weak in the face of the comparative might of the Irish State.

The event in Dublin was a State Occasion. The event in Milltown Cemetry was a farce. Street Theatre. Pantomime even. The sight of Sinn Féin members in uniform (of 1916 vintage) looked like Leonard, Sheldon, Howard and Raj showing up in uniform at a Star Trek Convention. So this made the man on the platform, Gerry Adams come across as William Shatner being the guest of honour…I bet he signed autographs.

 

 

 

 

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , | 8 Comments

Good Friday…The Drinks Are Not On Me

First of all a short statement. I dont drink alcohol and never have. My parents were lifelong pioneers and the only jewelry that my father left me was his pioneer pin. I tend to wear it on special family occasions.
There is an irony. My parents met in a pub. My father was a barman in the Grosvenor Road area and he placed an orange juice at my mothers left hand…to see if she was married or engaged. And the rest…as they say …is History.
My father did not particuarly like working in a pub. He always said that you met the “best people and the worst people” in pubs.
My mother on the other hand was very anti-drink. A pioneer pin was a sign that the young man courting a much loved neice was a good sign. Family members who were drinkers were “black sheep”.
My fathers family were non-drinkers. Back in my childhood, it was normal not to drink. And certainly among young people, especially girls, Drink was unacceptable.
In the 1960s, my father’s health declined and the only job that he could get was working in a sleaxy off-licence in a back street in West Belfast. The owner had a chain of sleazy off-licences and his employees were all former barmen who were in ill health. He had a reputation of being a good charitable Catholic businessman but of course he paid his employees a pittance….as a lot of good charitable Catholic business men were.
One of my fathers drink crazed customers hit him with a hammer and stole some cash and thereafter I (about 10 years old at the time) stayed with him after school until he closed up. My mother/younger sister did the same. He was never alone.
My father had a heart attack in 1965. The good Catholic businessman came to visit him, went upstairs and came down after a few minutes and nodded a platitude to my mother.
We wwent upstairs…my father was crying. He had been given two five pound notes and…the sack.
Of course my father never worked again. Sick Benefit the rest of his life. But he did live long enough to collect three years of Retirement Pension and (as he put it) “look every other man in the face”
My father was a forgiving man. When the good Cathoilic businessman died, he said a prayer for him. But my mother did not join in.

So in 2016, I dont know much about licensing laws (I have never had any need to know)but I know a lot more than I want to about the good Catholic businessmen. And a heck of a lot of them own pubs. Of course nowadays nobody is so common as to “own a pub” …we now call all this the Hospitality Industry.

Yet of all our pressing problems in Norn Iron, I am expected to believe that the biggest problem is “our antiquated licencing laws”. There are simply not enough hours in the day for people in the hospitality industry. Of course “hospitality” is all about fine wines at dinner…it is not about bottles of Bucky or anything so crude.
I dont know what the licensing hours are…but whether late in Belfast or any other town, I have not seen evidence that there are not enough hours in the day for people to get blitzed, pissed, drunk etc….in fact the evidence suggests that people drink rather more than they did in my day.
Not to be overly moralistic but a spokesman for the Hospitality Industry really needs to come on TV and say “to be brutally frank, we are in the business of selling drink and we want more time to do it”.

The pubs in Norn Ireland close for a few hours on Good Friday. And according to Social Media bemused tourists cant buy a drink. I have little sympathy for them. Tourism depends on “difference” and Good Friday is part of what makes Ireland “different”. A few hours once a year seems like no big deal. It is hardly as if we are asking tourists to sign the pledge or sign up to Ramadan.

It is no coincidence that the majority of pubs (and bookmakers) in Norn Iron are Catholic owned. It was a trade that respectable Protestants did not want to touch…and even today in Protestant dominated towns, the pubs (and bookies) will be disproportionately Catholic….good charitable men like the man who paid off my father with two five pound notes in 1965.

I could go all Biblical and say that doing without a drink for a few hours on Good Friday is no big deal. Watching just one hour …or three…with Jesus ….would cut no ice in 2016.

Tourists, Drinkers and the sharp suited spokespersons have their Rights. Yes of course….but in my experience Rights are only obtainable when they become economically viable.

Thus local business leaders who are so anxious to promote the “rights” of European workers to freedom of movement are the same people who tell us that “the right” of a worker to a Living Wage cannot be afforded.

RIghts…to Education, to Child Care, to Contraception….all based on Economics.

So I expect that the advocates for “modern” licensing laws are influenced by ….Cash. No harm in that of course. Just lets have some Honesty.

Yet it surprises me a little that the Hospitality Industry is targetting a fairly harmless (Christian) tradition. But it is a soft target….and I do not want to sound like a religious nutter on Fux News. There is no “War on Christianity” either in USA or in Ireland, north or south. I do not mind if you send me a Mass Card or a Sympathy Card. I will appreciate you shaking my hand and being sorry for my loss. I will attend any service and dont mind who attends mine. I will be happy for you to be with your spouse of any sexuality. I will respect your choice of wording “husband”, “wife”,”partner”, “boyfriend” , “girlfriend”. And all I ask is that you respect mine.

I will wish you “Happy Holidays”, “a Happy Christmas”, “Happy Chanukah”, “Happy Yule”.

If you invite me to a BarMitzvah”, “Holy Communion”, wedding in any church, registry office or forest glade, I will go.

Yet it seems to me it would be honest but counter-productive for the Hospitality Industry to simply say “we want to make more money”. Simply asking for longer opening hours would be a giveaway….so the rhetoric is about “modernising” the laws. So inevitably the Good Friday opening hours rooted in religious tradition seem a better way of putting it.

There is a myth that religious people are intolerant. Some are. Some are not. And there is a myth that athiests are tolerant. Some are. Some are not.

Certainly last years Referendum on Equal Marriage would not have been won if every Christian in the Republic of Ireland had voted NO.

If you prefer to think that Christians are intolerant, then that would be unfair to the son of a friends of mine who is working in a Presbyterian mission field in Malawi. And it would be unfair on the woman from St Vincent de Paul, fundraising for refugees in Greece.

So it seems that maybe a little tolerance can be shown to Christians. Those who oppose the “God Slot” Sunday programmes like “Songs of Praise” being on a public broadcaster like the BBC should know that it is right to cater to all minority tastes.

And those who get worked up about the RTE News being shown at 6.01pm because of the Catholic Angelus Bells chiming should realise that there is no praying….just people young and old and multi racial responding to the chimes with a moments silent reflection. It doesnt harm anyone.

A Christian might reasonably say that Good Friday is about a man who was born, lived, was crucified and lived beyond it. And reasonably enough an athiest might find that all to be nonsense.

But…heres the thing. I know a man who was born, was crucified during his life. And lives beyond his death. And probably so do you.

It may or may not be Jesus. But it does no harm to anyone to make space for that reflection once a year.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged | 1 Comment

Belgium and Europe

My sympathy to the people of Belgium.

The 24 hour News is almost unwatchable. Commentators and Politicians say it is too soon to discuss the implications and then proceed to do exactly that. They are effectively setting out the boundaries of the discussion.

It is deferrment. It will be no surprise if there is never any real discussion. Not even after the next attrocity in a different European capital.

Belgium is a strange country. Artificial. Set up in the early nineteenth century with th intention of keeping France and Germany from going to war. And as such…in 1870, 1914 and 1939, it has failed miserably.

Divided on language lines, Dutch, French and German and with an imposed monarchy and a grotesque empire in Congo, Rwanda and Burundi, it has been the centre of the great European experiment. Again, Peace in Europe. Is it already a failure.

Expanded Europe is a failed Europe. Democratic traditions in western Europe and the totalitarian traditions in the East. Money in the North. Basket case in the south. Hawkish, militaristic post colonials in NATO and honourable neutral nations.

I fear that sooner or later the contradictions within the European Union, as much as Belgium itself will eventually lead to failure or a recognition of failure. Later in this century, it will collapse. No Empire lasts and eventually the European Union will be a footnote in History.

It is not about BREXIT and Referendums. Whatever about the sideshow of European idealism and national sovreignty…so long as the EU exists, there is money to be made. It is still possible to milk the cash cow for all its worth before the cow is sent to an abattoir.

So long as Syria is being bombed by Russians, Americans and Europeans, refugees will come to “Europe” and of course there are economic migrants from North Africa. And there are refugees and/or migrants from Afghanistan.

Of course Racists see a bandwagon. Admitting “millions” (sic) of migrants will de-stabalise Europe further. Jihadis will mingle with the genuine refugees. It is always right to call out the Racists but just as important to call out the businessmen whos support for  open borders is as much about cheap labour as genuine human rights.

Europe with its “good friend” Turkey is now in the business of people trafficking.

That is the message that Europe sends out. It is understandable that French people gather in the Place de Republique. Understandable that Belgians gather in the Place de la Bourse. Understandable that French images have been replaced by Belgian images on Facebook.

Today the Belgian Flag flies in Dublin, London and other European capitals. People leave lighted candles and children draw peace symbols…..but surely there is a next time. And the politicians will lead the mourning and discourage scrutiny in the name of good taste.

The President of France says “Belgium was attacked….Europe was attacked”. Well, he is half-right. Belgium might have lost all its national identity (it never really had one) to be central to the European “ideal”. And if Francois Hollande thinks “Europe” was attacked, he means “Belgium/France/Germany/Britain/Netherlands” and the like. He does not mean “Sweden/Finland/Ireland/Slovenia/Latvia” …such is the nature of “Europe”.

But I think that an English voter watching the scenes at Brusells airport or listening to the French President might conclude that being European is not such a good idea. Calls for Solidarity ring hollow in places that dont show interest beyond the economic.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , | 2 Comments