CSI Belfast

CSI Belfast….is nothing to do with CSI Las Vegas, CSI Miami or CSI New York.

This is Cohesion, Sharing and Integration which should be a strategy for doing something about bringing the people of Norn Iron closer together. To tell the truth, nobody is really interested. Most of us think that we are ok as we are….we get on ok with Themmuns and basically we will get on a helluva lot better if people just leave us alone.

Getting on with each other is brilliant. Having an all-party (five party) coalition sit round a table and hammer out formal arrangements for getting along with each other is something that is too much work….best left to highly paid advisors and experts in Conflict Resolution.

Norn Iron is a divided society. There are actually FIFTY NINE walls, barriers or gates between the two tribes. NINE have actually been erected since the signing of the Good Friday Agreement. They are all in urban areas…Belfast, Derry and Portadown. The conventional wisdom is that this presents a very bad image of Norn Iron. But I think that is contradicted by the number of tourists who come to Belfast and gazing on our peace walls which (boohoo) tragically (sic) divide us is as important to the Belfast tourist industry as casinos are to Las Vegas, Mickey Mouse is to Florida and the Statue of Liberty is rot New York.

It is our Unique Selling Point. Therefore the walls will stay. But highly paid Conflict Resolutionists have to justify themselves….so it is hoped (says their latest document) that the walls come down by 2022. Good luck with that one. Helpfully they tell us that this will be achieved in full consultation with local people.

Alas the walls are there for a reason. These are interfaces which were makeshift barricades erected in 1969 and made better and bigger  by British Army engineers. Obviously this gave peace of mind to people who lived in these places but made policing much easier.

And they have stayed. Safety is also cited as the reason. But it is not the only reason. These are walls that seperate not merely warring factions. These are walls that seperate Britain from Ireland in a pachwork across Belfast. These ghettoes facilitate people being exactly what they are …British and Irish. And I suspect thats what really annoys the Conflict Resolutionists anxious to create a homogenous and frankly British society.

Yet it would be a mistake to think that peace “walls” are always visible. They are as much a part of a rural landscape as they are of the urban landscape. Norn Iron is a patchwork of towns with (to the locals) clear if invisible borders….and the patchwork of villages often only two miles apart are evidence of division….Protestant Aghalee is just two miles from Aghagallon. Protestant Birches just two miles from Catholic Maghery. Protestant Coagh just three miles from Catholic Ardboe. Protestant Moneymore three miles from  Catholic Draperstown. And so on. No “walls” …just fields with a load of sheep or cattle. But the local knows well enough where it is safe to wear the Rangers shirt. And where its safe to wear the Celtic shirt.

Indeed even in Belfast…the borderlines have been landscaped. The Westlink road links two motorways and at points along it provides a “natural” barricade. Living in this village, I am free to express my Irishness in any way I see fit…fly the flag while Ireland participates in international sport. Fly the Armagh flag when Armagh are involved in GAA Championship.

Why make Belfast different? Why make Belfast almost uniquely and by force homogenous. Of course there are plans afoot to regulate the flyining of flags (thats also hinted at in CSI document) but….ALL flags? The logical outcome of shared space is the “shopping mall” strategy…where the security staff will bar entry to people wearing a football shirt.

I have history here. Belfast always had “mixed streets”…streets which were not exclusively Protestant or Catholic. I lived in such a street in West Belfast. To our left and behind us was Protestant. To our right and in front of us was Catholic. Indeed we lived in the middle of the street (1951-1970) and although the demographics changed during those two decades, the middle of the street was more mixed than any other part of the street.

There was a certain etiquette …protocol to living in a mixed street. Some British flags DID fly around the Twelfth of July, in the late 1960s guarded by a bored young RUC officer from a nearby barracks…but in general there was a respect your neighbours ethos such as “dont play football on Sunday cos Protestants would be annoyed” but it always struck me that when I turned the corner into Catholic territory, I was more at ease. I could be…myself.

Of course part of the new CSI document is just risible nonsense. They are just making it up for a laugh. Take our divided education system……..which I think benefits nationalism and so I like it. After all nationalism is about highlighting those differences which make us uniquely Irish (or indeed British, French or Hungarian). Let me be clear I am NOT suggesting that Religion is or should be a marker of Irishness …merely saying that a homogenous Norn Iron is hardly in the nationalist interest. In contrast a homogenous society is (mostly) in unionist interest.

But take this gem. State schools……yeah verily even nursery (kindergarten) schools should have a buddy system where children are encouraged to befriend a child from the other tribe…they will be paired off. How unbelieveably sanctimonious and patronising is that?

A better idea might be if a child from affluent Cultra was encouraged to pair off with a Catholic child from disadvantaged Poleglass or a Protestant child from disadvantaged Lower Shankill Road……….ah say the Conflict Resolutionists thats er different.

It is risible.

I

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , | 21 Comments

“BackinBelfast”…I Have A Hashtag

Oh God no.

Traders in Belfast are having a hard time…economic downturn and for six weeks the Flegs Protestors have meant that a lot of people are not shopping, eating or drinking in the city. Even the tourists are turning their backs.

Earlier this week, TV News went to a bar where a delightful young barmaid was wearing a white and red T shirt, bearing the slogan”I’m Backin’ Belfast”. That’s what we need…a PR campaign and a Tshirt.

True to form and without a hint of irony,the politicians are backing the campaign. They are having a press conference today. DUP Mayor Gavin Robinson(he represents East Belfast) will be there. I don’t think he will be blaming his constituents who make up a large percentage of the rabble who are disrupting traffic and protesting in the city centre.

Yes that’s what we need…a PR campaign….and a Tshirt….and a DUP Mayor, backed by Sinn Fein holding a Press Conference. Is there anything that could make this even more nonsensical? Why not have Sinn Fein councillor and journalist, Mairtin O’Muilleoir congratulate the DUP Mayor for er…..holding the Conference, being young and name checking SF Councillor Deirdre Hargey, who is also er…young. What could make this even better?

Obviously we need a hashtag. All campaigns should have a hashtag. God knows how we campaigned before we had a hashtag. It is the reason we have that # symbol on our keyboards. What would Rosa Parkes and Dr Martin Luther King have done without a hashtag? Therefore we have a hashtag #BackinBelfast.

Congatrulations everyone. Problem solved.

The older I get, the more I realise that nothing is really new.

Back in the Spring of 1968, tJust beforeMy O Levels, there was a campaign called “I’m backing Britain” Britain under Harold Wilson was going thru a bad time and some scretaries in a firm in Surrey, decided to work an extra hour for no overtime. Harold Wilson liked the idea. Employers liked that idea. Trade Unions did not like that idea at all.

But Bruce FORSYTH LIKED the idea. Yes THAT Bruce Forsyth. He made a record called “I’m Backing Britain” and it flopped.

No hashtags in 1968 of course but newspaper magnate and crook, Robert Maxwell like the idea and threw the weight of the Daily Mirror behind it. He produced “I’m Backing Britain” Tshirts. The campaign fizzled out, not least because the Tshirts were made in ….Portugal. Alas the “I’m Backing Britain” Campaign is oonly remembered by old codgers like myself.

So for Belfast…we have Tshirts, a PR campaign, and a press conference. I don’t suppose Gavin Robinson, Mairtin O’Muilleoir and Deirdre Hargey are old enough to remember Bruce Forsyth singing “I’m Backing Britain” but I checked ….it’s available on YouTube.

I see that Belfasts last linen mill closed today. So where those Tshirts made in Belfast?

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Duncan Morrow

I see Duncan Morrow has been in a few TV studios lately. No longer in that Community Relations Quango, he is now on the staff at the University of Ulster.

Morrow is from a well known Alliance family, for whom I have a certain admiration. His late father Rev John Morrow being one of the most significant voices advocating Reconciliation.

But amid the talk of unionist re-alignment, I wonder if Duncan is considering being more overtly “political” . Could the Alliance Party be considering running him in the European Elections?

Just a thought.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , | 6 Comments

Patsy McGlone

I am pleased to see that Patsy McGlone has been selected to be SDLP candidate for the Mid Ulster bye-election. Excellent choice. Excellent candidate. I hold Patsy in the highest esteem. I will hopefully be in Cookstown, Magerafelt and Coalisland a few times during the campaign.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , | 4 Comments

Dolours Price RIP

Dolours Price died yesterday aged 61. She will be forever known as one of the Price Sisters and one of the Old Bailey bombers in 1973, when she was just 22 years old. The Old Bailey bombers received long jail sentences and were forced fed while on Hunger Strike.

Some will have little sympathy for them. Others will. In passing, I should point out that some so called journalists and bloggers are using their so called professionalism to hide their gloating.

For them the only issue is…Ms Prices involvement in the disappearance of Jean McConville, murdered in 1972. Mrs McConville who had ten children was abducted and murdered in the belief that she was an informer. She is the favourite victim of a certain kind of journalist and blogger. Whether Ms Price was merely a pawn in 1972 or even 1973 is one thing. She has certainly been a pawn in recent years. Suffering mental health problems, she has been shamelessly used by journalists and bloggers to discredit Gerry Adams, who allegedly ordered the abduction and murder in 1972. While Mrs McConville is the favourite victim, Gerry Adams is their favourite pantomime villain.

Adams of course does himself few favours. I hold no brief for him. Nor do I hold any brief for journalists and “researchers” who seem to have more interest in pursuing their agenda than genuine archiving of the Troubles history.

Jean McConville was murdered in 1972. The Old Bailey Bomb was in 1973. A lifetime ago. Those rushing to type their blogs and rush to the moral high ground where they feel they belong will probably have to spend several minutes on the Internet trying to find the name of the man who died of a heart attack as a result of the Old Bailey Bomb. Not that it will matter much to the moralists but his name was Fred Milton.

But of course today’s stories are not really about Fred Milton. Or even Dolours Price. Or even Roisin McNearney ( look her up, I can’t do everything) who fared rather better than Dolours Price.Gerry Kelly, one of the bombers who suffered horribly thru forced feeding Has ended up ok…Sinn Feins spokesperson on Policing and Justice.

A Lifetime ago. There’s something odd here. Dolours waspish was 22. Marion Price was 19. Hugh Feeney was 21. Gerry Kelly was 20. Roisin McNearney was 18. ….I was 21.

All were from West Belfast. A specific area of West Belfast, which they would have called the Second Battalion area. Parishes…St Peters, St Johns, St Pauls, Clonard Monastery,…..places like Kashmir Road, Whiterock Road, Falls Road, Springfield Road,…..Royal Victoria Hospital…Mackies Foundry. Schools like St Dominic’s, St Roses, St Louise’s,….teacher training college at Trench House. Casement Park, the White Fort Bar…..ok you get the picture. It I was a small localised world…and no we didn’t know e everybody…that would be ridiculous….but if we didn’t know everybody, we knew their parents, brothers, sisters, cousins or neighbours.

Or if we didn’t know them in 1972 and 1973….we might have known them in 1965 or 1966.

A Time and a Place. I have written before of that Phoney War from 1970 to 1971, when they all paraded up the Falls Road in their battalions and companies. And it all seemed lika adventure like the Christian Brothers and Sisters of Mercy told us around the time of the Fiftieth Anniversary of the Easter Rising in 1966.

And I have written about that arc of events in 1971/72 which changed my life….Internment, McGurks Bar, Bloody Sunday, Claudy and Bloody Friday.

I am not of course saying that everything after the summer of 1972 settled me completely into the person that I am today.

Did I mention that I am 60 years old? Oh I did…Married 30 years. Two sons. Two Daughters in Law and three surviving grandchildren. I am lucky.

Dolours Price…Rest in Peace.

There but for the Grace of GOD.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , | 10 Comments

From The Crazy World Of Modern Jacobites

Heres an interesting piece of news from the world of “modern” (dont snigger) Jacobitism.

One of the most interesting Catholic Churches in London is “Our Lady of the Assumption and St Gregory” which is in Warwick Street near Piccadilly Circus. As you will see from the Plaque, it dates back to Penal Days when it was only possible to hold Mass in embassy chapels. At the time of the 1745 Jacobite Rebellion the Church was the embassy chapel of Portugal but passed to the Bavarians soon after. As such it is held in high esteem by the tweedy nutcases in modern Jacobitism.

The rather pleasant and totally blameless current Duke IN (sic) Bavaria is “King” Francis I, who would much prefer if his Jacobite subjects would just leave him be. He is much too polite to tell them that they are the czaziest fools that he has ever had the misfortune to meet. Indeed he is currently undergoing treatment for cancer.

The plaque inside the church was erected after the death of “King” Robert I in 1955. And has been a source of extreme embarassment to English Catholicism ever since. Trying to build bridges with the Windsors, it has been tiresome to say the least to have Jacobite reminders about the place.

In the past….the Archdiocese of Westminster has designated the Church as being the chaplaincy for London’s hotel and catering workers…Irish, Spanish, Italian and not exactly upper class. The Jacobites didnt like that. Even more recently the Diocese has used the Church as a chaplaincy for Londons Gay, Lesbian and Transgendered community. The Jacobites liked that even less. I dont understand that as the brother of Bonnie Prince Charles, Henry IX , a Catholic Cardinal was in fact a homosexual.

The Church has now been handed over to the Ordinature of Our Lady of Walsingham, which has a direct connexion to Pope Benedict XVI and is made up of ex-Anglican priests who converted to Rome because the Church of England over women priests.

So two sets of nutters then. And they have a common cause. Without “Westminster” direction, the tweedy Jacobites think that they now have a better chance of getting a memorial erected to “King Albert”, who succeeded Robert. Albert died in 1996.

I wont be holding my breath.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , | 4 Comments

Playing The Ball(Boy)

Just when you think that you’ve seen everything on…and just off…a football field, along comes Swansea City versus Chelsea. I did not actually get to see the match util about ten minutes to go…and the commentators were already talking about the “extra-ordinary” sending off.

So after the match, I got to see it. Edin Hazard of Chelsea sent off for violent conduct…on a ball boy.

That probably sounds worse than it is. The ball boy was in fact 17 years old…not 12 years old.

Certainly…extra-ordinary. To be fair, over the seasons, I have noticed at times…a certain atmosphere between “away teams” and ball boys. And indeed match day staff. According to Glenn Hoddle (last night) the balls boy are ” instructed” to speed up or slow down returning the ball, with the best interests of the home team involved. He called it part of the home teams advantage. That’s a bit sad…and no pun intended but not part of the level playing field culture.

A certain gamesmanship is always expected. But the normal courtesies should apply.

TV replays of the incident are inconclusive. It DID seem that earlier in the match, a different ball boy was slow to get the ball back…and Chelsea players seemed already frustrated. The incident itself seems to suggest that the ball boy fell on the ball…or threw himself on the ball…as Hazard approached him to hurry up. Then Hazard appeared to kick the ball from underneath him…connecting with him in the process.

It should not come as any surprise that “violent conduct” applies, not just to players on the opposing team. It applies to everyone in the ground. Hazard was duly sent off and will miss three games.

Football fans are tribal. This could have happened to ANY “away” team. Thank GOD it was not Manchester United. But there seems to be something inevitable about the fact that it was…again…Chelsea. As I have said before…Chelsea aerie unloved…to the point of being toxic.

You can’t buy CLASS. And there was not much class about last nights incident. And Chelsea have now a long established reputation For lacking class.

All is well that ends well. A handshake between ball boy and player after the game and the suspicion that the ball boy who called himself the King of the Time Wasters in a pre-match “tweet” is at least partly to blame…will remove some or all of the poison. But.Boyer another unseemly incident for the Beautiful Game…and Chelsea.

The Ball Boy will have his fifteen minutes of Fame, interviews and public appearances arranged by an agent…and Hazard get a three-match ban.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Peter O’Connor 1906….Rory McIlroy 2016.

Interesting thread on Slugger O’Toole ….where yet again the vexed question of the nationality of Rory McIlroy is discussed.

A matter for himself of course. He might declare for Britain. He might declare for Ireland. Or indeed neither. It is noted that he might be able to compete as an individual…but that seems unlikely. The example of athletes from the Netherlands Antilles (2012) is not appropriate. Rory might well consider himself to be “northern Irish” but if he is to compete in the Olympic Games as a golfer in 2016, it won’t be for Norn Iron…or as an individual.

There is simply no way that the International Olympic Committee will allow it. it would be a can of worms. There are almost certainly British athletes who would prefer to compete for Scotland…and probably others who would prefer to compete for Wales.

Not to mention…people from Katanga, Biafra, Bavaria and Quebec.

Yet….the most obvious precedent is missed by Slugger O’Toole.

In 1906, three athletes were sent from Ireland to compete for Ireland in the Athens Games. As Ireland had no National Olympic Committee but found that they were assigned to the British team. One…Peter O’ Connor won a Gold and Silver medal. At the Medal Ceremony the British flag was flown. O’ Connor did not like this and aided and abetted by Irish and Irish-American athletes scaled the flagpole and replaced it with an Irish Flag (the Erin go Bragh flag).

Will Rory climb a flagpole in Rio with a Norn Iron fleg?

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , | 2 Comments

Howdy Texans

Just two weeks to Texas. And an opportune time to welcome some Texan folks who have been given a link or about to be given a link to this Blog.

It might be helpful if I set out some explanatory notes. The Most Frequently Asked Questions that nobody has ever actually asked.

Keeping An Eye On The Czar of Russia……this references a mid nineteenth century small town newspaper., The Skibereen Eagle. The Editor of the paper notoriously commented on world events. One was about potential Russian expansion …warning that the newspaper was “keeping an eye on the Czar of Russia”. I believe that all Bloggers delude ourselves that we have any importance or influence.We are at heart no different from the pompous editor of  a small town Irish newspaper. For all the modernity of the Internet, it is not that much different.

Fitzjames Horse….references an 18th century Franco-Irish cavalry regiment. it has no other significance other than being a subject in which I am interested.

Subject Matter….inevitably there are some lighter cultural references. but most of the Blog is about (north of Ireland) politics. Politics is essentially short term but I like to see Politics in a historical context. The cliche that History repeats itself may only be partly true…but I am now 60 years old and over the course of my adult life have seen things happen which do have a historical precedent or near-precedent. To understand Politics is not just to understand different philosophies or media…the proper understanding of Politics requires an understanding of History.

Partisanship….essentially there are two tribes …and possibly even three tribes in Norn Iron. While I myself am a member of the moderate nationalist/republican/socialist  SDLP, this blog reflects the fact that I am broadly Irish nationalist, republican and socialist. I don’t think that this invalidates the Blog in terms of Honesty. I think a partisan blog CAN be honest. I think that reading different partisan blogs, properly argued is a better approach than reading bi-partisan blogs who try too hard to be balanced.

The Political Spectrum in Norn Iron….there are five main parties in Norn Iron. Sinn Fein (republican and closely linked to the IRA), SDLP (moderate republican), Alliance Party (agnostic on the constitutional status), UUP (moderate unionists who backed the Good Friday Agreement in 1998) and DUP (who signed up to an amended version some years later). All these Parties are involved in a power sharing Government with the extremes SF and DUP being the most powerful and in control. The two republican parties are socialist in nature. The two unionist parties are conservative in nature.

Conflict Resolution…a vexed subject with me. The Troubles 1969 to Good Friday Agreement in 1998 actually fizzled out in the early 1990s. The Agreement is based on the concept of Creative Ambiguity…complex and occasionally contradictory and necessarily vague, it was accepted by an overwhelming majority of nationalists and a narrow majority of unionists.

The Good Friday Agreement is failing…or as I believe already failed. Key proposals were never implemented. A Bill of Rights, an Irish Language Act, a means of dealing with Victims, a means of addressing the Past…none have happened. The Agreement itself has been further undermined by an amendment, the St Andrews Agreement, largely to get the DUP on board.

The vacuum has been filled by…among others…Conflict Resolutionists, who are second-guessing the Agreement.

Conflict Resolution….most conflicts are resolved.In the American context, at Yorktown, at Appomattix and on board USS Missouri, conflicts were resolved. This involved the complete defeat of entire nations and/or ideas and the complete victory of others. The subsequent Peace was based on that.

The Northern Ireland Troubles ended in stalemate. A mantra that we were all victims and that we were all to blame replaced any real Peace. The undermining and failure of the Good Friday Agreement has faciliated conflict resolutionists and a succession of ad-hoc, sterile proposals from academics and seemingly well financed (by Government and others) think tanks who are relentlessly imposing a Peace…as they think it should be.

There is a cliché that Peace should be more than the absence of War. But in the situation where we agreed in 1998 that there were no winners and no losers, it is a nonsense that a Settlement beyond that agreed should be effectively imposed, settling the winning and losing debate.

The Future….the absence of violence and the removal of the most blatant forms of injustice have produced a strange passivity. This is being pushed towards an acceptance of a broader status quo…the acceptance of a United Kingdom. It is a simple fact that Irish nationalism, to which I am fully committed thrives on a sense of Injustice. For me there is a small fear that removing injustice actually strengthens my traditional enemy.

Demographics….the recent Census (December 2011) is perhaps a watershed. The stark figures are that Norn Iron is now 48% Protestant, 45% Catholic with 7% Other. Protestant and Catholic are essentially inter-changeable terms with Unionist and Nationalist…..but only about 42% of population vote for nationalist parties. There is a shortfall in nationalist votes, mostly explaned by the agnostic Alliance Party.

The spread of this significant Catholic/Nationalist demographic……..much higher in the rural south and west and narrowly higher in Belfast…means that Protestants/Unionists are now clustered in large areas of population around Belfast and in County Antrim and north County Down.

More importantly, it means that Protestants are now a minority in the state that was created specifically for them and can no longer maintain a Unionist majority by relying on their core support but must reach beyond that. Their committment to do so…and their ability to do so is a major doubt.

The Flags/Flegs Dispute.…this is a dispute ongoing for seven weeks now. Starting on 3rd December 2012. And probably sums Norn Iron up better than any history book. Belfast City Hall…iconic for Unionists has been flying the British Flag on a daily basis for over a century. But the demographics of the City has changed to the extent that the City Council is now 24 Nationalists (SF & SDLP) 20 Unionists (mostly DUP) and 6 Alliance Party holding the balance of power.

The proposal that the British Flag be brought down was made by Nationalists and predictably opposed by Unionists. The Alliance Party proposed a compromise that it fly on a specified number of days (nineteen) to mark public occasions such as the birthday of a member of the British Royal Family. This compromise was passed angered Unionists to the extent that Belfast and other places have had often violent protests…and perhaps ironically and predictably the relatively harmless Alliance Party has taken most of the flak. I recommend that you read the blog posts which reference the Flags/Flegs dispute.

So again…welcome to this Blog. Looking forward to seeing you all in Texas.

 

 

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , | 5 Comments

Killer Wales

Strange that there has been an interview with”Prince Harry” in which the guy who dressed up as a Nazi to party in England and dressed down to party in Las Vegas, admits to have killed Taliban in Afghanistan.

Of course the object of the exercise for soldiers is to kill the Enemy. So it can hardly be a surprise that Harry has killed. What is a surprise is the candid admission that he has killed, the handling of it by “royal” press people and the fact that it has published. Public reaction is also going to be interesting.

Of course there considerations. Just how legitimate is the use of an Apache helicopter gunship in Afghanistan? And if any women and children got killed by Harry, would that be a game-changer? After all, I read an agonised thread on a well known discussion board yesterday condemned the use of drones by United States. If an Apache gunship killed Afghan civilians by a man third in line to the British throne hands killed civilians, then surely it would be consistent for that discussion board to nuclear (no pun intended).

For people of my vintage, this is strange. The British Constitution demands that the Monarchy remains in the shadows, which means that no spotlight is shone on the Institution.

In the 1960s Huw Wheldon and the BBC persuaded the “royal Family” to let the cameras in. In the 1980s, “Prince Edward” brought the cameras in to “It’s A Royal Knockout”, Will the Harry interview be as big a disaster?

Perhaps Harry leaping in and out of helicopters legitimises the war. Perhaps it rehabilitates the guy. Or perhaps the Royal handlers arrunning losing the run of themselves. Mrs Windsor jumped out of a helicopter and it went well. Lets have Harry jump into one.

Of course this isn’t fiction. And as Harry’s dad….er I mean Charles prepares to be the Defender of Faiths, Harry killing Islamic terrorists might be a bit controversial. …with Britains Islamists making him a target….or making the country a target.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , | 6 Comments