Part Four — A Little Bit of Sauce
As everyone knows, I am hilarious.
Unfortunately, not everyone agrees.
By the late 1960s, British comedy was undergoing something of a revolution. The old restrictions were weakening, the permissive society was arriving, and comedians were discovering that there were things you could now say on television that would once have resulted in a stern letter from the BBC.
Naturally, much of this newfound freedom was devoted to sex.
Or, more accurately, talking about sex without actually mentioning it.
The British had elevated the double entendre into something approaching a national art form. A raised eyebrow, a meaningful pause, a suggestive remark, and the audience knew exactly what was intended.
Enter the Carry On films.
Sid James, Kenneth Williams, Hattie Jacques, Joan Sims, Charles Hawtrey, Barbara Windsor and the rest of the company became familiar faces to millions.
The early films had generally been affectionate send-ups of British institutions: hospitals, schools, the police and the armed forces.
Later came historical adventures, exotic locations and increasingly elaborate excuses for somebody to lose their trousers.
The films were inexpensive, cheerful and frequently ridiculous.
They were also enormously popular.
Kenneth Williams could turn an innocent sentence into something positively scandalous simply by adjusting his expression. Sid James needed only to laugh. Barbara Windsor could cause a national sensation with a malfunctioning bikini.
And Hattie Jacques, often cast as the formidable authority figure, could reduce the entire male cast to terrified schoolboys.
The humour was frequently childish.
But childishness, properly executed, can be very funny.
There was also something reassuring about the regular cast. Audiences knew what they were getting. The actors played variations on familiar characters, and much of the pleasure came from watching them do it again.
The Carry On films were not alone.
Frankie Howerd was enjoying renewed popularity, especially with Up Pompeii!, in which ancient Rome became a convenient setting for modern innuendo.
And then there was On the Buses.
Stan Butler, Jack Harper and Inspector Blakey occupied a world of bus depots, conductresses, domestic arguments and sexual frustration.
It was hugely popular.
It was also, viewed today, astonishingly sexist.
Women were frequently presented as either objects of pursuit or figures of ridicule. The male characters were often rewarded for behaviour that would now attract considerably less sympathetic attention.
The television series was successful enough to produce three feature films.
And this brings us to an interesting question.
Were audiences in the 1970s fundamentally different from audiences today?
Or were they simply accustomed to different rules?
I suspect the answer is both.
The jokes were products of their time, but they also helped reinforce the assumptions of that time.
It is possible to remember laughing at something without insisting that it remains funny today.
It is equally possible to recognise the prejudices in old comedy without pretending that nobody ever enjoyed it.
By the middle of the 1970s, the British sex comedy had become a genre in its own right.
The Confessions films, starring Robin Askwith, abandoned much of the relative innocence of the earlier Carry Ons in favour of more explicit situations.
The formula was straightforward: an improbable occupation, an even more improbable collection of attractive women, and a young man who appeared to have extraordinary difficulty keeping his clothes on.
Nobody was likely to mistake these productions for Shakespeare.
Although, come to think of it, Shakespeare was hardly a stranger to a dirty joke.
There was something peculiarly British about the whole business.
A society that had spent generations insisting that sex should not be discussed in polite company suddenly found itself discussing almost nothing else.
Yet the humour remained full of embarrassment, euphemism and anxiety.
The sexual revolution had arrived.
The British were still looking for somewhere to put their trousers.
I don’t believe we should approach the comedy of the past with either unquestioning nostalgia or automatic condemnation.
Some of it was brilliant.
Some of it was dreadful.
Some of it was both.
And much of it tells us a great deal about the society that produced it.
The laughter was real, even when the assumptions behind it deserve examination.
Which brings us to another branch of British entertainment.
The comedians who didn’t need a script, a fictional bus depot or a collapsing bikini.
They needed only a microphone, an audience and a collection of jokes.
And in 1971, television gave them their own programme.
Next: Comedy Tonight — Part Five: The Comedians.